Boothe was a consensus All-American and three-time first-team All-Ivy pick for the Big Red. A second-team Sports Newtwork All-American in 2005, he was a tri-captain in his final season in Ithaca and a four-year starter. A unanimous first-team All-Ivy pick in each of his final two years, he became just the fourth Cornell player to earn first-team all-league honors three times. A sixth round pick in the NFL Draft by the Oakland Raiders, he played a decade in the NFL and won two Super Bowl rings with the New York Giants.